National Pie Day is upon us, and what better way to celebrate than by indulging in some of the finest pies that Long Island has to offer? Whether you're a fan of classic fruit pies, creamy custards, or savory selections, Long Island's bakeries and farm stands have something to satisfy every pie lover's palate. Here's a curated list of top spots to find the best pies on Long Island, along with their contact information and any specials they might be offering for National Pie Day.
1. Briermere Farms
Located in Riverhead, Briermere Farms is renowned for its delectable pies made from scratch using fruits grown right on their farm. Their offerings include classics like apple, blueberry, and raspberry, as well as unique cream pies such as peach cream and raspberry cream. It's worth noting that Briermere Farms is closed for the season from Christmas Day until Spring 2025, but they are open for online jam orders.
- Address: 4414 Sound Avenue, Riverhead, NY 11901
- Phone: 631-722-3931
- Website: briermerefarms.com
2. Jericho Cider Mill
With a history dating back to 1820, Jericho Cider Mill offers a mouthwatering selection of pies, including apple, blueberry, peach, cherry, and raspberry. Their apple-cranberry pie is particularly iconic, balancing tart cranberries with sweet apples.
- Address: 213 Jericho Oyster Bay Road, Jericho, NY 11753
- Phone: 516-433-3360
- Website: jerichocider.com
3. Alpine Pastry Shoppe
Family-owned and operated, Alpine Pastry Shoppe in Smithtown is known for producing an astounding array of delicious pies, including pecan, coconut-custard, and pumpkin. Their coconut-custard pie is a standout, offering a sweet, creamy reminder of warmer weather.
- Address: 59 Route 111, Smithtown, NY 11787
- Phone: 631-265-5610
- Website: alpinepastryshop.com
4. Hallock's Cider Mill
Situated in Laurel, Hallock's Cider Mill is celebrated for its apple crumb pie, featuring thinly sliced, cinnamon-spiced apples topped with a crunchy, sweet crumb. It's the perfect dessert for fall and beyond.
- Address: 1960 Main Road, Laurel, NY 11948
- Phone: 631-298-1140
- Website: hallockscidermill.com
5. Round Swamp Farm
Located in East Hampton, Round Swamp Farm is known for its high-quality produce and prepared meals. Their pies are a local favorite, offering flavors that highlight the freshness of their farm-grown fruits.
- Address: 184 Three Mile Harbor Road, East Hampton, NY 11937
- Phone: 631-324-4438
- Website: roundswampfarm.com
6. Carissa's The Bakery
With locations in East Hampton, Carissa's The Bakery offers a variety of pastries and pies that have garnered praise from locals and visitors alike. Their commitment to using local ingredients ensures a fresh and flavorful pie experience.
-
Address:
- 68 Newtown Lane, East Hampton, NY 11937
- 221 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937
- Phone: 631-604-5911
- Website: carissasthebakery.com
7. Youngs Farm
Founded in 1893, Youngs Farm in Old Brookville bakes fresh pies on premises, with a selection that includes apple, coconut, dark cherry, pear, peach, and many more. Their long-standing tradition ensures a pie that embodies the essence of homemade goodness.
- Address: 91 Hegemans Lane, Glen Head, NY 11545
- Phone: 516-626-3955
- Website: youngs.farm
8. Loaves & Fishes
Featured in Grace Coddington's guide to the Hamptons, Loaves & Fishes is known for its delicious pies and fresh lobster. It's a go-to spot for those seeking high-quality, gourmet pies in the Hamptons area.
- Address: 50 Sagg Main Street, Sagaponack, NY 11962
- Phone: 631-537-0555
- Website: loavesandfishes.us
National Pie Day Specials
While specific National Pie Day specials for 2025 have not been announced, it's common for bakeries and eateries to offer promotions such as discounts