Long Islanders, get ready for a treat that will be available year-round! Mister Softee, the beloved ice cream brand known for its signature jingle and nostalgic ice cream trucks, is setting up a permanent brick-and-mortar location in East Islip. This exciting development means that locals will no longer have to chase down the truck for their favorite soft-serve cones, shakes, and sundaes—soon, they’ll be able to enjoy them any time of year at a fixed location.
The new store is taking over the space formerly occupied by Pam’s Ice Cream Shoppe at 195 Carleton Avenue. Pam’s, a community staple for many years, officially closed its doors on January 14, leaving locals wondering what would take its place. Now, the mystery has been solved: a Mister Softee sign has gone up at the location, signaling the arrival of the brand’s first-ever brick-and-mortar shop on Long Island.
A New Chapter for Mister Softee on Long Island
For decades, Mister Softee has been a summer icon, delighting both children and adults with its fleet of blue and white trucks roaming neighborhoods across Long Island. The sound of its signature jingle has been synonymous with warm-weather indulgence. However, for ice cream lovers, the experience often comes with a bit of anticipation—waiting to hear the chimes, hoping the truck stops on their block, only to see it turn the other way.
With the upcoming opening of the East Islip store, that wait-and-see element will be eliminated. Fans of Mister Softee can simply walk into the shop and enjoy their favorite frozen treats whenever they please.
While Mister Softee has been a household name for generations, its foray into brick-and-mortar locations is a relatively new endeavor. The company has established a few fixed locations in New Jersey, but this will be the first time Long Islanders get to experience their favorite soft serve in a permanent setting.
What to Expect at the New Mister Softee Location
Though full details about the menu have yet to be released, customers can expect all the classic Mister Softee offerings. That means sprinkle-packed cones, perfectly swirled soft serve, rich milkshakes, and indulgent double-dipped cones.
Beyond the traditional soft-serve selections, it’s possible that the new location may expand its menu to include specialty sundaes, custom ice cream cakes, or other exclusive treats that are difficult to serve from a mobile truck. Some of the brick-and-mortar locations in New Jersey have already experimented with these additions, and Long Island’s first store may follow suit.
Why East Islip?
East Islip is an ideal location for Mister Softee’s expansion. The area has a strong sense of community, with many families and long-time residents who enjoy supporting local businesses. The store’s location on Carleton Avenue is centrally situated and easily accessible, making it convenient for both East Islip locals and visitors from surrounding neighborhoods.
Pam’s Ice Cream Shoppe previously served as a go-to spot for ice cream in the area, and Mister Softee’s arrival ensures that East Islip’s legacy as a haven for sweet treats continues.
The Rise of Ice Cream Shops in Long Island’s Food Scene
The addition of Mister Softee to Long Island’s growing ice cream scene is part of a broader trend. More and more ice cream brands are seeing the value in establishing year-round locations rather than solely relying on seasonal operations. In recent years, several popular ice cream trucks and roadside stands have transitioned into permanent storefronts, giving customers greater access to their favorite frozen treats no matter the season.
For Mister Softee, this move represents a strategic shift. While the brand remains committed to its mobile fleet, having a physical storefront allows for a broader customer base and the ability to serve ice cream lovers even during the colder months. With Long Island’s unpredictable weather, this is a game-changer for fans who crave their soft-serve fix regardless of the season.
When Will the East Islip Location Open?
While no official opening date has been announced, the installation of the sign indicates that construction and preparation are well underway. Long Island ice cream lovers should keep an eye out for an official grand opening announcement in the coming months.
In the meantime, locals can start dreaming about the endless possibilities—whether it’s enjoying a classic vanilla cone with rainbow sprinkles, a rich chocolate shake, or an extravagant sundae loaded with toppings.
A Sweet Future for Long Island
With Mister Softee planting its roots in East Islip, this could be just the beginning of more brick-and-mortar locations to come. If the concept proves successful, there’s potential for additional permanent storefronts in other parts of Long Island, giving even more communities access to this beloved brand’s signature treats year-round.
For now, Long Islanders can look forward to experiencing Mister Softee in a whole new way. Whether you’re a longtime fan of the ice cream truck or a newcomer eager to try the classic flavors, one thing is certain—Mister Softee’s arrival in East Islip is a sweet victory for all.