Long Island is renowned for its picturesque beaches, charming towns, and vibrant communities, but it's also a culinary treasure trove waiting to be explored. From the North Fork’s fertile vineyards to the South Shore’s seafood shacks, Long Island offers a diverse and delectable food scene that satisfies every palate. Join us on a culinary tour of Long Island as we uncover some must-try dishes and restaurants that showcase the best of what this region has to offer.
North Fork: A Gastronomic Haven
1. The Frisky Oyster - Greenport
Located in the heart of Greenport, The Frisky Oyster is a standout dining destination known for its innovative and mouth-watering dishes. A must-try is their famous “Frisky Oysters,” served with a unique watermelon mignonette that perfectly balances the briny oysters. The restaurant’s chic, yet casual ambiance makes it a perfect spot for a memorable meal.
2. North Fork Table & Inn - Southold
A staple in Long Island's fine dining scene, the North Fork Table & Inn is celebrated for its farm-to-table philosophy. The restaurant’s seasonal menu highlights local produce and seafood. Don’t miss their signature dish, the “Roasted Long Island Duck,” which is prepared to perfection and showcases the rich flavors of the region.
3. Love Lane Kitchen - Mattituck
For a more relaxed dining experience, head to Love Lane Kitchen in Mattituck. This cozy eatery is beloved for its welcoming atmosphere and delicious comfort food. Their “Fish Tacos,” featuring locally caught fish, are a favorite among regulars. Pair it with a glass of wine from a nearby vineyard for the complete North Fork experience.
South Shore: Seafood Galore
4. The Clam Bar at Napeague
No visit to Long Island is complete without indulging in some fresh seafood, and The Clam Bar at Napeague is the perfect place to do just that. This iconic roadside seafood shack offers an array of fresh catches, but their “Clam Strips” and “Lobster Rolls” are truly exceptional. Enjoy your meal with a view of the stunning Napeague Bay.
5. Peter’s Clam Bar - Island Park
Peter’s Clam Bar has been a South Shore institution since 1940, serving some of the best seafood on Long Island. The “Clam Chowder” here is legendary, with its rich, creamy broth and generous portions of tender clams. The waterfront setting adds to the charm, making it a great spot for a laid-back seafood feast.
6. Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams - Rockville Centre
For those who crave fried seafood, Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams in Rockville Centre is a must-visit. This family-owned spot has been dishing out golden, crispy clams since 1939. Their “Fried Clam Platter” is a crowd-pleaser, served with coleslaw and tartar sauce. It’s comfort food at its finest.
The Hamptons: Elegant Eats
7. Nick & Toni’s - East Hampton
Nick & Toni’s is synonymous with the Hamptons’ upscale dining scene. This beloved restaurant offers a Mediterranean-inspired menu with an emphasis on local ingredients. A standout dish is the “Wood-Roasted Chicken,” cooked to juicy perfection in their wood-fired oven. The rustic-chic setting and celebrity sightings add to the allure.
8. Topping Rose House - Bridgehampton
Housed in a beautifully restored 19th-century mansion, Topping Rose House offers a luxurious dining experience. The menu features modern American cuisine with a focus on farm-to-table freshness. The “Grilled Montauk Swordfish” is a highlight, served with seasonal vegetables sourced from local farms. The elegant atmosphere makes it perfect for a special occasion.
9. The Lobster Roll - Amagansett
Affectionately known as “Lunch,” The Lobster Roll in Amagansett is a Hamptons landmark. This casual spot is famous for its namesake dish, the “Lobster Roll,” which is packed with tender lobster meat and served in a perfectly toasted bun. It’s a quintessential Hamptons dining experience that shouldn’t be missed.
Nassau County: Diverse Delights
10. Kyma - Roslyn
For a taste of the Mediterranean, head to Kyma in Roslyn. This elegant restaurant specializes in Greek cuisine, with an emphasis on fresh seafood. The “Grilled Octopus” is a standout, tender and flavorful with a perfect char. The chic, whitewashed decor transports you straight to the Greek islands.
11. Umberto’s Pizzeria & Restaurant - New Hyde Park
No culinary tour of Long Island would be complete without some Italian fare, and Umberto’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a local favorite. Their “Grandma Pie,” a square pizza with a thin, crispy crust, fresh tomato sauce, and mozzarella, is legendary. It’s a comforting slice of Italy right in New Hyde Park.
12. The Witches Brew - West Hempstead
For a unique dining experience, visit The Witches Brew, a quirky cafe in West Hempstead. This eclectic spot is known for its extensive vegetarian and vegan menu. The “Vegan Chili” is a hearty and flavorful dish that even meat-eaters will love. The whimsical decor and cozy vibe make it a great place to unwind.
Suffolk County: Local Favorites
13. JT’s on the Bay - Blue Point
JT’s on the Bay in Blue Point offers stunning waterfront views and a laid-back dining experience. The menu features a variety of seafood dishes, but the “Blue Point Oysters” are a must-try, harvested right from the local waters. Enjoy them with a refreshing cocktail as you take in the beautiful bay views.
14. The Plaza Cafe - Southampton
Located in Southampton, The Plaza Cafe is a fine dining restaurant that specializes in seafood. The “Pan-Seared Scallops” are a highlight, served with a delicious corn and lobster risotto. The elegant setting and impeccable service make it a top choice for a sophisticated night out.
15. Cowfish - Hampton Bays
Cowfish in Hampton Bays offers a creative blend of surf and turf dishes. The “Cowfish Burger,” topped with bacon, cheddar, and a fried egg, is a hearty and satisfying choice. The waterfront location and lively atmosphere make it a popular spot for both locals and visitors.
Long Island's culinary scene is as diverse and dynamic as its landscape. From fresh seafood shacks to elegant fine dining, there’s something to satisfy every craving. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this culinary tour highlights some of the must-try dishes and restaurants that make Long Island a true gastronomic destination. So, grab your appetite and start exploring the delicious flavors of Long Island today!
We'd love to hear about your favorite Long Island eateries and dishes! Share your top picks and food experiences with us on social media using the hashtag #LongIslandEats. Bon appétit!