In the heart of Jericho, New York, sits a property that should, by all accounts, be prime real estate for a successful restaurant. Located at 399 Jericho Turnpike, the site boasts a sizable 3,800 square feet of commercial space, ample parking for patrons and staff, and an attractive layout featuring two dining rooms, a private dining room, a bar lounge, and a reception area. Yet, despite these attributes, the location has proven to be a challenging venture for several restaurants, the latest being Lisbon Grill and Cozumel. After each opened to hopeful beginnings, both restaurants have closed, leaving the address once again available for lease and the local community wondering: why can’t a restaurant succeed here?
The Rise and Fall of Lisbon Grill
Lisbon Grill was, for a time, a standout dining option in Jericho. The restaurant’s commitment to authentic Portuguese cuisine drew patrons looking for something different from the typical American, Italian, or Asian fare in the area. Lisbon Grill offered a rich menu featuring classic Portuguese dishes like grilled sardines, piri-piri chicken, and bacalhau (salted cod). Its warm, inviting atmosphere made it popular among locals and Portuguese cuisine enthusiasts alike. For many, Lisbon Grill was a refreshing alternative, and it quickly became a favorite spot for those seeking to enjoy an international dining experience.
Despite its popularity, Lisbon Grill shocked its patrons by closing down. The abrupt end came as a surprise, leaving patrons disappointed and sparking questions about what had gone wrong. The restaurant’s closure marked the end of a beloved establishment and the beginning of another chapter in 399 Jericho Tpke’s tumultuous history.
The Quick Appearance and Departure of Cozumel
Almost as quickly as Lisbon Grill departed, Cozumel moved in, bringing a completely different dining concept to the address. Cozumel’s Mexican-inspired cuisine was poised to attract a diverse customer base. The restaurant’s offerings included classic Mexican dishes like tacos, enchiladas, and fajitas, hoping to bring a taste of Mexico to Jericho. Cozumel was a complete reimagining of the space, designed to attract the young families and professionals that populate Jericho and surrounding areas.
However, Cozumel’s journey was even shorter than its predecessor’s. Within weeks of its opening, Cozumel quietly shut its doors, leaving 399 Jericho Tpke vacant once more. The brief lifespan of Cozumel, following so closely on the heels of Lisbon Grill’s closure, cast a spotlight on the address, raising questions about the viability of any business in this space.
A History of High Turnover
Lisbon Grill and Cozumel are not the first restaurants to try and fail at 399 Jericho Tpke. The address has a history of high turnover, with multiple restaurant concepts attempting to make a name there, only to ultimately fall short. Previous restaurants at this address have included a variety of cuisines and business models, each bringing its own unique style and menu. Yet, none have managed to stick around long-term.
This pattern of short-lived tenancies suggests that there may be underlying challenges with the location itself. Local rumors have circulated, speculating on everything from poor visibility and accessibility to high operating costs. Whatever the cause, the high turnover rate has led some to dub 399 Jericho Tpke the “cursed location.”
What Makes 399 Jericho Tpke Challenging?
There are several potential reasons why 399 Jericho Tpke has seen such a rapid turnover of tenants. Each of these factors may contribute to the address’s struggle to sustain a successful, long-term business.
1. Visibility and Foot Traffic
While Jericho Turnpike is a busy thoroughfare, the location of 399 Jericho Tpke may not be as visible as it appears on paper. Restaurants rely heavily on visibility and foot traffic to attract customers. If a potential customer can’t easily see the establishment while driving by, it significantly impacts the restaurant’s ability to draw in new patrons. While Lisbon Grill and Cozumel both had loyal followings, visibility may have hampered their ability to attract new customers on a consistent basis.
2. Parking and Accessibility
The flyer promoting the lease lists ample parking with a 30-car capacity, along with dedicated employee parking. However, parking convenience doesn’t necessarily translate to accessibility. If the layout of the parking lot or access points from the road create difficulties for customers, it can lead to frustration and deter them from visiting. Furthermore, Jericho Turnpike’s fast-moving traffic and limited turning options might complicate access to the restaurant, making it less appealing to potential diners.
3. High Operating Costs
Running a restaurant in Jericho can be expensive, with rising costs for rent, utilities, and staff. The cost of leasing a 3,800-square-foot space is substantial, and the expenses only grow when factoring in staffing for multiple dining rooms and a bar. For independent restaurateurs, these costs can be prohibitive, especially if customer volume does not meet expectations. Without a steady stream of new and returning customers, restaurants at 399 Jericho Tpke may struggle to break even, leading to early closures.
4. Local Competition
Jericho and its surrounding areas are home to a wide variety of dining options, ranging from high-end restaurants to fast-casual eateries. For a new restaurant to stand out, it needs to offer something unique that isn’t readily available elsewhere. While both Lisbon Grill’s Portuguese fare and Cozumel’s Mexican cuisine provided interesting alternatives, the sheer number of nearby restaurants may have diluted their appeal, making it difficult to attract a consistent customer base.
The Impact on the Community
The constant turnover at 399 Jericho Tpke does more than affect the business owners; it also impacts the community. When a restaurant closes, it can create a sense of loss for regular patrons who form emotional connections to their favorite local spots. Each closure at 399 Jericho Tpke has likely disappointed loyal customers and disheartened those who hoped to see a long-standing establishment thrive at this address. Additionally, the frequent vacancies create a negative visual impression, with empty storefronts that might dissuade other businesses from investing in the area.
What’s Next for 399 Jericho Tpke?
As 399 Jericho Tpke remains vacant and available for lease, the big question is: what can turn this location into a thriving business? The property flyer presents the address’s potential with enthusiasm, highlighting the spacious layout, the parking, and the multi-room setup that could accommodate various dining concepts. Perhaps a different approach is needed to break the cycle of closures.
Potential Concepts for Success
-
Unique and Untapped Dining Concepts: A highly specialized restaurant that caters to a niche market could bring the novelty needed to attract a dedicated customer base. For example, a plant-based or fusion cuisine restaurant could capitalize on current food trends that are underrepresented in the area.
-
Community Engagement and Marketing: A strong emphasis on community events, like cooking classes, tasting events, or live entertainment, could build stronger ties with locals and encourage repeat visits.
-
Non-Restaurant Business Models: While 399 Jericho Tpke is marketed as a restaurant space, perhaps a non-dining business could find success here. A boutique grocery store, a co-working café, or even a hybrid food market might offer the variety and convenience that could be better suited to the area’s needs.
-
Optimizing Accessibility and Customer Experience: A strategic redesign of the property’s entrance and parking layout might help mitigate some of the accessibility challenges. Simple adjustments could make a significant difference in customer convenience and satisfaction.
The story of 399 Jericho Tpke is one of potential unrealized. The address has seen a parade of restaurants come and go, each hopeful to establish a thriving business, only to close within a short time. As the property remains vacant once more, it serves as a reminder that certain locations, regardless of their attributes, face unique challenges that require thoughtful strategies and a deep understanding of the local market. While it remains to be seen who will take on the next chapter at 399 Jericho Tpke, one thing is clear: any future tenant will need a plan to defy the odds and bring long-term success to Jericho’s elusive address.
